This is the first compilation I’ve read by these authors, but I’m very familiar with and love all their series. It was fun reading about my favorite characters celebrating Halloween. Any of these stories could be read and a person wouldn’t feel lost if they haven’t read any of the series, especially the Hayley Powell story, Death by Haunted House, which I explain in my Goodreads review below.
I’m a little weird about liking to read books in order, and if you are like that too, Barbara Ross’s website has the numbering for all of her books and short stories showing how they fit into the regular Maine Clambake series. Hallowed Out is book 7.5. It looks like this is the group’s first Halloween compilation. Now I’m looking forward to reading one of their Christmas compilations!
My rating: 5 of 5 stars
There were three really fun mysteries in this compilation. I love all these authors’ series to begin with, so I wanted to finally read one of their holiday collections, and since Halloween is my second favorite holiday, (Christmas being my first fave), I couldn’t resist requesting it from NetGalley.
The first one, Haunted House Murder, is a Lucy Stone mystery and is actually a shorter missing person type of mystery, but the other two did have the expected murders, and I didn’t guess the killers in either of one of them. I couldn’t believe that Lucy’s grandson Patrick is already eight years old.
In the Hayley Powell mystery, Death by Haunted House, readers don’t have to be worried at all if they haven’t read any other Hayley Powells, because this one takes place before the series even started. It was fun getting an insight into what Danny was like as a husband (kind of goofy and didn’t think things through a lot.) The first two books definitely had a similar theme: don’t judge your new neighbors by what they appear to be.
In the last mystery, Hallowed Out, by Barbara Ross of the Maine Clambake series, there was a really interesting murder that took place during a ghost tour reenactment. I loved that Le Roi the cat unraveled something that was bothering Julia a little bit. After reading this, I realized that it’s been far too long since I read a Maine Clambake mystery, and that I need to read one soon.
I voluntarily read and reviewed an ARC of this book provided by the publisher via NetGalley, and my opinions are my own.